top of page
  • Writer's pictureGFP Staff

A Proper Good Meal 

Updated: Jun 29, 2023

The Proper Pie is a bright and welcoming spot tucked away in the corner of a strip mall. Hungry visitors can order dishes like fish and chips, tea and scones or grab a pie from the refrigerator, take it up to the counter to pay, and have them bake it for you (or grab something to go). The restaurant is adorably decorated to fit an English aesthetic, with street signs, street names, and a bright red telephone booth. They offer a vast and well-priced selection of iconic English fare, including frozen take-home pot pies, scones, "chips," and the like. They also have a huge offering of English chocolates and treats! Try the perfectly crumbly scone slathered with delicious clotted cream and jam with a spot of tea served in a charming traditional teapot with cups and saucers to boot.

Meal to Mention: Fish and Chips with house-made tartar sauce – The fish was huge and crispy, and the chips were fat and delicious (though we prefer traditional tartar sauce over the house-made).

Honorable Bites: "Shepherd's pie inside of a pie" and the chicken, leek, and potato pie – They were delicious, full of meat, and the crust was so good.

GFP Hot Tip: Grab some London Bangers from the fridge and have them baked – they're pretty darn good, mate!

The Proper Pie Company

511 Hwy 17 92 W, Unit 520, Haines City, FL

(863) 438-2705

FB: The Proper Pie Company


bottom of page